I was very disturbed when the other day I heard a Norwegian official defending whaling on the grounds of it being a tradition and ecological ocean management. When in fact it is merely the barbaric torture and slaughter of an intelligent creature that we know so little about for commercial reasons. I could buy the tradition argument in Iceland or Norway's case if they went out in rowing boats and hand threw harpoons at any that they happened to see while not grafting at the oars. Other than a few coastal villages, the Japanese have only been eating whale since the Second World War, so there is no cultural excuse.
There's nothing traditional or humane about chasing down whales using sonar in diesel powered death cruisers and firing a harpoon tipped with a hand grenade then hauling it back to ship, shooting at it with rifles and hanging it upside down with blowhole subsurface so it drowns to death before craning it into a factory ship for processing into Minke burgers for the rich consumers of this food. There is no humane way to slaughter an animal this size. It should be stopped.
Japan and Norway are expected to slaughter around 2000 whales this year, for "Scientific Research" as there has been an IWC moratorium on commercial whaling since 1985/6. Although exactly why you need to kill 2000 whales a year for research and how putting the meat on supermarket shelves constitutes scientific research is a bloody mystery. Every year many whales become stranded in shallow waters for reasons we do not understand, if scientific research is necessary, these could be used. If you wanted to study what is man would it be easier to do with 2000 corpses ? This wednesday Greenpeace Germany parked the 20 tonne carcass of a fin whale that had become stranded on the Baltic coast and died, outside the Japanese embassy in Berlin to demonstrate this point.
Every year, the Japanese bribe poor nations with no interest in whaling to join the IWC in order to help them tip the balance at the next vote in the hope that they can gain some quasi-official sanction for their continuance and increase of this dirty trade.
A Japanese whaling ship rammed the Greenpeace vessel harrying them in the southern ocean earlier this month, if you can afford to do something to help them or are just interested, go here.
Bastards!
Meanwhile, today in London, a 7 tonne bottlenose whale has found itself swimming up the Thames past The Houses of Parliament and everyone concerned is trying to gently persuade it to swim back out to sea. Now isn't that a better approach?
11 comments:
Jase i agree totally. Plus, I had no idea there WERE 2000 whales left for Japan and Norway to kill.
The Norwegian govenment estimates huge numbers of Minke, but only because they want excuses to kill more. Go here for something more trustworty: http://www.doc.govt.nz/Conservation/001~Plants-and-Animals/003~Marine-Mammals/Whales/100~Conservation-of-whales-in-the-21st-century/050~Whale-numbers.asp
I've added a bit more...
Actually, the japanese have had a whale hunting tradition dating to several hundred of years back "http://luna.pos.to/whale/jwa_trad.html" and it is said that the modern Japanese whaling industry started around 1899.
Even though I've had the experience of eating whale meat (not very tasty by the way), I think that defending a particular species, while keeping our meat-eating habits of other species is quite debatable. To me, eating whale meat can be regarded as bad as eating cow, pork, or "bush meat" (gorillas, chimps and the like).
I'm not vegetarian, but I think we should be aware of our inherent "predator" culture, regarding the way we treat our planet companions. This way we can start looking for alternatives to our current dietary habits.
Now, here's another "interesting" approach to protesting...
http://www.thesun.co.uk/article/0,,2-2006030144,00.html
If you read what I said again you will note that I stated that outside a few coastal villages the Japanese do not have a whale eating tradition. It was not mainstream fare for Japanese people. That the Japanese government is now trying to rewrite history so that the whole of the country appear to have been whale eaters for 400 years does not make it true.
Also rereading my post you will note that what I am focusing on is not the eating it is the slaughter. The slaughter of a whale follows a totally different approach to that of a cow and takes longer.
Of course you can look at different animals differently, I am quite happy pulling the shell off of an oyster and eating it live, breaking the legs off of a live cow, or blow torching a goat are totally different.
I don't know if you've ever read any books about beef or other animals raised for food, but they do not fare a whole lot better, at least in the U.S. (Don't even get my started on policy on big business vs. the enviroment in general here. I voted, and not for him.) Fast Food Nation and similar books will make you think twice about where you get meat, and whether you even want to eat it at all. For the record, I'm veg, but not vegan, for a variety of personal reasons - but co-exist peacefully with my omnivorous friends and family.
What I'm saying...is that the whole whaling thing stinks, but I want to save them all :)
Steph, you are a sweety!
Jase;
I had to read this and come back and read it again. Small world; I teach a course related to this topic and my students and I spend time discussing issues related to the marine environment. This is one of them. I agree with your position on whaling.
Sealing is an entirely different thing, however, which the media has spun completely out of perspective and control.
Hope you are well.
Cathy
Glad you are back, I've missed you! I did some work for Greenpeace many years ago. This subject, as most of their others still touches me. Unfortunately the whale in the Thames died today as they tried to save it.
We should do more to help big dumb animals - I'm gonna ring Joe and checks he's OK. If whales are so clever why do they keep swimming near Japan though ??
Good point Colm.... It's a good job they dont hunt whale in Brazil or Colombia, Joe would be toast.
Post a Comment